I had hoped to begin this week by celebrating the fact that despite the recession, your generosity has put our UNM United Way campaign within $25,000 of its unprecedented (and some believed unattainable) goal of $1 million.
I wanted to discuss the fact that today is UNM Day at the Roundhouse – and urge you to join us to remind our Legislature of the importance of UNM to our students, our patients and the economy of this state.
However, in light of the petition last week by a small minority of the faculty alleging a “crisis of confidence,” I will instead address the charges in that petition. This University has too much at stake right now for the widening of divisions that might be caused by delay.
Regarding Administrative Growth:
In terms of the administrative changes at UNM, I have done exactly what I promised to do.
The entire substance of my agreement with the Regents has been based upon clearly-articulated performance objectives and publicly-available routine progress reports, which are posted online at Office of the President.
At every public forum before my selection, I promised to elevate four positions to Cabinet level: Diversity, Enrollment Management, Athletics and Rio Rancho Operations/Branch Campuses. Let me restate the reasons I gave, and the accomplishments we’ve achieved together since then:
Diversity:
At each of those public forums, I was told that our student population was not being reflected in the faculty or the administration, and that women in particular were virtually absent from the ranks of University senior leadership. Pledging to reverse that situation, I’ve since been privileged to hire five executive administrators, four women, two Hispanic. We’ve also expanded our recruitment of minority students, and I’m especially proud that the number of National Hispanic Scholars has more than doubled during my tenure.
Enrollment Management:
One of the biggest problems we faced when I arrived here was stagnant enrollment, which is still costing us greatly in terms of state funding formulas. By elevating Enrollment Management to a Vice Presidency and beginning the consolidation of Admissions, Financial Aid and Registration, we’re now reaching out more effectively to the most promising prospects and giving them better service.
As of this writing, new graduate student enrollments are up 25.76% this spring (the highest number of new graduate enrollments at UNM in four years), and new graduate student applications are up 53%. Freshman applications for the spring, 2009 semester were up 59% over the year before and our freshman class last semester was the biggest ever, a 10% increase over the previous year. The number of National Merit Scholars increased almost threefold and our National Hispanic Scholars more than doubled since we formed the Division. The number of National Scholars applying to UNM has likewise gone from 40 last year to more than 100 as of today.
Athletics:
Athletics should be an integral part of the University, not a self-governing entity off to itself. By elevating the Athletic Director to Cabinet-level status, athletics is now involved in every University decision that bears on its mission. By making athletics academic advisors directly responsible to the Provost (rather than the Athletics Director, as used to be the case), we are better meeting the educational needs of our student athletes.
Rio Rancho Operations and Branch Campuses:
We have an obligation to better serve the needs of both our four branch campuses and the fast-growing communities to our north, where our efforts (now moving forward under the supervision of the Vice President of Rio Rancho Operations) have been overwhelmingly supported by local taxpayers who last year voted increases in the Gross Receipts Tax and supported local bonds to fund UNM’s expansion. I’m also pleased to report growth at each of our existing branch campuses.
UNM Spends Less on Administrative Costs than our Peers, With Administrative Pay Below Market:
For 35 years now, I’ve been a faculty member, an administrator and President of three universities, and let me be clear: nobody wants needless or excessive administrative costs. Every rational educator knows that our prime responsibilities are teaching and research.
That’s why I supported the faculty’s request last year for a comprehensive review of main campus executive salaries, and took the additional step of resolving to update the study annually. The Comprehensive Review report was the work of a joint committee comprised of faculty members and University Human Resources staff, and is available on our website at Comprehensive Review.
Comparing UNM’s upper administration to those of our peer institutions, the joint faculty-staff Comprehensive Review confirmed that UNM’s upper
administrators – just like our faculty and staff generally – are paid at or below market, and that UNM devotes a smaller percentage of its expenditures to administration than do our peers, with a greater percentage of our expenditures going toward our core missions.
In addition, the Comprehensive Review by faculty and Human Resources found that:
- While UNM upper administration has grown since 2002, its growth was largely the result of changes in the leadership model and administrative consolidation over the past five years, during the tenures of three different UNM Presidents.
- While it’s true that compensation for upper administration positions above the level of Dean increased 42.1% between 2002 and 2007, management responsibilities grew even faster during this period, as operational revenues increased by 60.1%, from $1.2 to $2 billion (published reports claiming a 71% increase in compensation for these positions were factually inaccurate).
Fiscal Responsibility and “harvesting”:
Since the current financial crisis began to unfold, I have been sharply criticized for my decision to revert, or “harvest,” remaining fund balances and to impose a pause on hiring, pay raises and promotions.
These were difficult decisions, especially so since we had previously reserved more than $1 million in I&G College Fund balances for additional faculty and graduate fellowships. They were necessary, however, so we could meet the contingency of a mid-year budget rescission by the Legislature.
Now, as we begin to see the outlines of the state’s Solvency Plan, it’s becoming apparent that those sacrifices were amply justified: they appear to have helped us avoid the much more painful outcomes that our counterparts have had to undergo. At Arizona State and other public universities, for instance, employees are being forced to take non-paid furloughs.
Most importantly, we’ve so far managed to avoid the layoff or furlough of even a single one of our 22,000 employees. In fact, the one University office that sustained the greatest reduction in spending was my own.
Change in Focus:
Nevertheless, with resources in decline, we must do all we can to concentrate on the things that matter most – teaching and research.
Consequently, last week I directed a 15% reduction in non-academic main campus administrative spending, together with the hiring of 10 additional full-time tenure-track faculty over the next 3 years.
At the same time, we placed an immediate and indefinite freeze of all increases in compensation for me, the 3 Executive Vice Presidents and all main campus Vice Presidents, together with a suspension through FY 2010 of compensation increases for main campus non-academic administrators earning more than $125,000 annually.
We’re also in the process of developing a comprehensive university policy on deferred compensation, which we will submit to the Board of Regents at their regular April meeting.
Improvements in Research Administration:
My larger point is this: whenever issues have been addressed to me, I’ve been diligent in getting to the truth, transparent in making the facts known, and quick to implement the needed reforms.
One example is the reform of Research Administration following criticisms by the Research Study Group and the Executive Research Advisory Committee (ERAC).
Thanks to the dedication and boldness of Dr. Julia Fulghum and her team, Research is successfully managing its deficit. It has doubled the number of staff in Sponsored Projects Services, placed grants experts directly within the colleges and schools to better facilitate the preparation and submission of proposals and worked closely with Business and Finance to streamline purchasing.
Responsiveness and Transparency:
In each of my dealings with UNM faculty, staff, students and alumni and the outside community at large, I’ve done my best to be forthright, even when I knew my message would be unpopular. I’ve tried to make myself accessible, reaching out to the University community frequently, using every means I could think of.
There’s no doubt I’ve made misjudgments. Mistakes are inevitable, and the only shame is failing to own up to them: I’ve always tried to acknowledge and correct the ones I’ve made.
Now is the time for unity and Stability of Leadership:
I know that the current economic crisis has made all of us anxious and fearful, but I call to mind the words of Abraham Lincoln: “A house divided against itself cannot stand.”
When I was first approached about serving at UNM, I was told I would be the sixth President of this University in the previous 10 years – the highest turnover of Presidents at any of the flagship universities. We aren’t doing our students or ourselves any good with a revolving door at the President’s office. Without consistency and stability, there can be no direction or leadership.
In the midst of a deep recession, with the Legislature trying even now to close a half-billion-dollar budget shortfall and Congress considering unprecedented commitments to higher education, this is no time for the UNM community to be a house divided against itself. Instead, we should be pulling together, as one, to remind the Legislature of UNM’s importance and to urge Congress to move forward with aid to higher education as part of the Fiscal Stimulus.
Already, the Legislative Finance Committee has recommended reductions in Higher Education funding of $20.1 million. What troubles me most is that while UNM represents only 37% of higher education spending, we’re being asked to shoulder 47% of the cuts. It’s a distribution that I don’t believe is fair. I’m also concerned about Special Projects funding for our ethnic student service centers, which fulfill a vitally important role in helping minority students reach their full potential.
As I said when I took office, a University should never be a quiet place: it should be alive with the free expression of bold ideas and views strongly held. It should, however, be a considerate place, where civilized men and women are always willing to listen to one another in an atmosphere of mutual respect.
So, for the good of our entire University community and in the interests of the students and taxpayers we serve, let’s reject the shouting, the sneers and the jeers, and instead join together, as reasonable men and women, to dedicate ourselves to our real mission – teaching our students, healing our patients and conducting the important research that will alleviate suffering and expand man’s knowledge.
David J. Schmidly
Recent Comments